The first person to notice a brain injury is often not the patient. It is the spouse who hears the same question asked three times at dinner, or the parent who sees a teenager lose his temper over nothing, weeks after a crash or fall that everyone thought was minor. A brain injury claim in Virginia moves through a predictable set of milestones, and families who know what comes next make fewer costly mistakes along the way. If someone close to you is not the same since an accident, a Richmond traumatic brain injury lawyer at Tronfeld West & Durrett can tell you where the claim stands and what it needs.
Milestone 1: Someone Notices the Change
Brain injury claims rarely start with a dramatic diagnosis. They start with small observations that add up, and the people who make those observations become some of the most important witnesses in the case.
The timing is part of what makes these injuries easy to miss. The National Institute of Neurological Disorders and Stroke advises watching for new signs such as mood swings or unusual irritability, noting that they may be related to the injury even when they appear several weeks later. What families describe at home usually looks like this:
- Memory gaps. Missed appointments, repeated questions, forgotten conversations.
- Mood and personality shifts. Irritability, flat emotions, or anxiety that was not there before.
- Trouble with ordinary tasks. Paying bills, following a recipe, or keeping up at work suddenly takes far more effort.
- Physical signs that linger. Headaches, light sensitivity, dizziness, and poor sleep weeks after the accident.
Symptoms like these sometimes develop into post-concussion syndrome, which can last months. A family member who writes down dates and specific examples is building evidence without realizing it, and our attorneys use those notes to show a jury who the person was before the injury.
For answers to your questions, call:
800-321-6741
Milestone 2: A Diagnosis That Matches the Symptoms
The second milestone is getting the medical record to reflect what the family is seeing, which is harder than it sounds.
Emergency rooms focus on life-threatening injuries. A CT scan that rules out bleeding is good news for the patient, but insurers later point to that “normal” scan as proof that nothing was wrong. Many brain injuries, including diffuse damage and the coup and contrecoup injuries caused by the brain striking both sides of the skull, do not show up clearly on standard imaging.
The diagnosis usually comes together through a sequence of providers: a primary care or urgent care follow-up, a referral to a neurologist, and then neuropsychological testing. That testing measures memory, attention, processing speed, and executive function against expected norms, putting numbers on deficits that a scan cannot display. Our firm helps clients reach the right specialists so the medical file tells the same story the family has been telling.
Milestone 3: Identifying Who Is Responsible and Which Policy Pays
Once the injury is documented, the claim turns to two questions: who caused it, and how much insurance stands behind that party. The answers depend on where the injury happened.
Crashes
In a collision, the at-fault driver’s auto liability policy is the first source of payment. Virginia’s minimum limits are low compared with the cost of a serious brain injury, so the claim may also involve your own underinsured motorist coverage, an employer’s commercial policy, or more than one at-fault driver. When damages outrun the available coverage, the options after a crash exceeds insurance limits become central to the case.
Falls and Falling Objects
Stores, landlords, and contractors owe visitors reasonable care. A head injury from a fall on a hazard or an object dropped from above can support a premises liability claim, and a business usually carries commercial coverage well above personal auto limits.
Medical Care and Other Settings
Oxygen deprivation during surgery or a missed bleed in the emergency department can lead to a medical negligence claim, which follows different rules and a statutory damages cap.
Finding every defendant and every policy is often worth more than any argument about the injury itself. That investigation is one of the first things Tronfeld West & Durrett does in a brain injury case.
Click to contact us today
Milestone 4: Waiting for the Medical Picture to Settle
This is the milestone families find hardest, because it involves waiting. Doctors use the term maximum medical improvement to describe the point where recovery has leveled off and the lasting effects can be measured. For a brain injury, that point can come many months after the accident.
Settling before then means trading an unknown future for a fixed number. If a person turns out to need job retraining, supervision at home, or years of cognitive therapy, a release signed too early cannot be reopened. Meanwhile, families can find support through the Virginia Department for Aging and Rehabilitative Services, which runs brain injury services across the Commonwealth.
While the medical team works on recovery, our legal team works on the record: gathering bills and wage losses, lining up expert opinions, and keeping the insurer from closing the file cheaply.
Complete a Free Case Evaluation form now
Milestone 5: Filing Suit and Facing the Defense
When negotiations fail, a lawsuit gives the claim new tools and exposes it to new pressure. Several things happen in a Virginia brain injury suit that families should expect:
- The two-year deadline controls the timing. Most injury suits must be filed within two years of the injury, so waiting for maximum medical improvement sometimes means filing first and finishing treatment during the case.
- The defense examines the injured person. Under Rule 4:10 of the Rules of the Supreme Court of Virginia, the court can order a physical or mental examination by a provider the defense selects when a party’s condition is in dispute. Defense neuropsychologists often conclude the deficits are mild or unrelated.
- Depositions test memory directly. A person with a brain injury may not recall the accident, and defense lawyers use that gap to suggest the plaintiff shares the blame.
- Fault arguments carry extra weight. Under Virginia’s contributory negligence rule, a finding that the injured person was even slightly at fault can bar recovery entirely, so we build the liability case from scene evidence and witnesses, not from the client’s memory.
Each of these steps is a place where a claim can lose value. Our attorneys prepare clients and family witnesses for all of them and use proven methods to establish negligence in Virginia injury cases independent of what the injured person remembers.
Milestone 6: Resolution and Court Approval
Most brain injury claims end in a negotiated settlement, a mediated agreement, or a verdict. One extra step applies when the injured person is a minor or an adult who can no longer manage their own affairs. Under Va. Code § 8.01-424, a court can review and approve a settlement on behalf of a person under a disability, which protects the injured person and makes the settlement binding.
Families in this position often need a guardian, conservator, or special needs planning so that settlement money does not disrupt benefits. Tronfeld West & Durrett helps families plan for those pieces so the resolution serves the injured person for the long term.
Jay Tronfeld on What Families Should Do First
Jay Tronfeld, a founding shareholder of Tronfeld West & Durrett with more than 50 years of Virginia personal injury practice, offers this advice to families:
“In a brain injury case, the family usually knows before the doctors do. I ask spouses and parents to start a notebook the day they notice something is off: what happened, when, and who else saw it. Months later, when the defense doctor says the test scores look fine, that notebook and the people who kept it are what show a jury the real loss.”
Two of our firm’s results show how far an injury claim can go when the invisible harm is documented. In a retail store under renovation, a contractor working above a display case accidentally kicked a steel-framed cardboard sign weighing about 11 pounds, and it struck a customer in the head. The work area had not been roped off, and no signs warned of overhead work. That traumatic brain injury claim resolved for a $1.3 million settlement. In a different kind of case, a hotel housekeeper was burned when a natural gas dryer exploded, and her claim included the extreme anxiety and post-traumatic stress disorder that followed. It settled for $4,000,000. Both cases depended on proving harm that went beyond what an X-ray or scan could capture.
Talk to a Virginia Brain Injury Lawyer
If the person you love is struggling after an accident, you do not have to sort out the legal side alone. Our Virginia brain injury lawyers are local attorneys, born and raised in Virginia, and we are not your typical law firm: we get to know the family, not just the file.
Contact us to set up a free consultation at a time that works for your family. There is no fee unless we win.
FAQs About Brain Injury Claims in Virginia
How much compensation do you get for a brain injury?
There is no set amount. Compensation reflects medical costs, lost income and earning capacity, future care, and the effect of the injury on daily life, and it is limited in practice by the insurance available. A mild concussion with full recovery may resolve for a modest figure, while a permanent injury that ends a career can support a far larger catastrophic injury claim.
How do you prove a TBI in an injury claim?
Proof usually combines medical records from the date of the accident, imaging where it shows damage, neuropsychological testing, treating physician opinions linking the injury to the event, and testimony from family, friends, and coworkers about the change in the person. Missing any one piece gives the insurer an opening.
Can you make a claim for a concussion?
Yes. A concussion is a mild traumatic brain injury, and it can support a claim when someone else’s negligence caused it. Many concussions heal within weeks, but some leave headaches, memory trouble, or mood changes that last for months. Whether a concussion claim is worth pursuing depends on that medical course, so keep every follow-up appointment.
How long do I have to file a head injury claim in Virginia?
In most cases the lawsuit must be on file within two years of the injury, as Va. Code § 8.01-243 provides. The period is usually paused for an injured child until age 18, and claims against government bodies have shorter notice deadlines.
Should we wait for a full recovery before calling a lawyer?
No. Waiting for recovery before settling is wise, but waiting to get advice is not. Evidence such as surveillance video, vehicle data, and witness memories fades quickly, and deadlines keep running while treatment continues.
Call or text 800-321-6741 or complete a Free Case Evaluation form
