If someone borrows your car and gets into an accident, determining who is responsible for the damages can be complicated. In most cases, car insurance follows the vehicle, meaning that the car owner’s insurance policy is primarily responsible for covering the damages. However, the specifics depend on whether the driver had permission, the type of insurance coverage available, and the circumstances of the crash.
Does Insurance Cover Someone Else Driving Your Car?
1. Did the Driver Have Permission to Use Your Car?
The first question insurance companies ask is whether the person driving had your explicit or implied permission.
- Named Insured: If the driver is listed on your policy as a named insured, they are automatically covered.
- Verbal Permission: If you gave the driver permission to use your car, your insurance should cover the damages just as if you were driving.
What If the Driver Exceeded Their Permission?
If the person borrowed your car for one purpose but used it for another before crashing, coverage may be contested.
For example, if you let a friend borrow your car to pick up groceries, but they decided to run additional personal errands and crashed while outside the scope of permission, your insurer might deny the claim, requiring the driver’s insurance to cover the damages.
2. Virginia’s Omnibus Clause & Family Members
Virginia automatically assumes that family members who live in your household—including spouses, children, and even college students who list your home as their permanent address—have permission to drive your car, even if you don’t explicitly grant it.
Unlike some states, Virginia does not allow policyholders to exclude specific drivers from their insurance coverage. This means that if a reckless or high-risk family member crashes your car, your insurance will likely still be responsible, potentially leading to higher premiums.
For answers to your questions, call:
800-321-6741
What If Someone Takes Your Car Without Permission?
If someone steals your car or takes it without your consent, liability may shift to the driver’s personal insurance (if they have coverage). However, if there is a history of prior permission, insurance companies may argue that the driver believed they had permission, making your claim more complicated.
For example, if you previously allowed a friend to use your car weekly, and they took it one day without asking, your insurance company may still be liable, depending on the circumstances.
Who Pays for Damages After an Accident?
Determining financial responsibility depends on state laws, insurance coverage, and who was at fault:
- If the Driver Had Permission – Your car insurance will likely cover the damages first. The driver’s insurance may help cover any remaining costs beyond your policy limits.
- If the Driver Exceeded Permission – The insurance company may deny the claim, and the driver may have to use their own insurance or pay out of pocket.
- If the Car Was Taken Without Permission – The driver’s insurance (if applicable) should cover damages, but if they are uninsured, you may need to file a claim under your own policy.
- If the Car Was Stolen – You should report the theft immediately. Any damages caused by a thief are typically covered under comprehensive insurance (if you have it).
Click to contact us today
What About Rental Cars and Borrowed Vehicles?
When renting or borrowing a car, insurance coverage can be complex. Before driving a rental or lending your vehicle, consider:
- Does your personal auto policy cover rental cars?
- What coverage does the rental company provide?
- Does the person borrowing your car have their own insurance?
Many insurance policies extend to rental cars, but not all do—always check your policy before assuming you’re covered.
Complete a Free Case Evaluation form now
Need Help After a Car Accident? Contact a Virginia Car Accident Lawyer
Sorting through insurance claims, liability issues, and denied coverage can be overwhelming. At Tronfeld West & Durrett, our Richmond car accident lawyers help clients navigate Virginia’s complex insurance laws to protect their rights and maximize their compensation.
Call 804-358-6741 today for a free consultation and let us help you understand your options.
Call or text 800-321-6741 or complete a Free Case Evaluation form